The Allahabad High Court has banned the recruitment process for 72825 posts of assistant primary teachers in the state (Uttar Pradesh ), the ban is due a special appeal in High Court .
News Board
शिक्षक भर्ती मामले में राज्य सरकार 11 फरवरी को हाईकोर्ट में स्थिति स्पष्ट करेगी। मंगलवार को बेसिक शिक्षा विभाग के अधिकारियों की बैठक में भर्ती प्रक्रिया का रिकॉर्ड एकत्र करने को कहा गया। इस आधार पर प्रति शपथ पत्र तैयार कर उस पर कानूनी राय लेने के बाद हाईकोर्ट में 11 फरवरी को इसे दाखिल किया जाएगा। विभाग का मानना है किभर्ती प्रक्रिया के लिए उसने जो नियमावली तैयार की है, उसमें कोई खामी नहीं है। हाईकोर्ट स्थिति स्पष्ट होने के बाद भर्ती प्रक्रिया पर लगी रोक को हटा देगा।
According to Amar Ujala ( A popular Hindi News Paper in North India ) :-
विशेष अपील में एकल न्यायपीठ के 16 जनवरी के आदेश को चुनौती देते हुए कहा गया कि न्यायपीठ ने प्रदेश सरकार द्वारा टीईटी को मात्र अर्हता मानने के फैसले को स्वीकार कर लिया है। चूंकि शिक्षा का अधिकार अधिनियम 2009 एक केंद्रीय अधिनियम है और उसके तहत प्राप्त अधिकारों द्वारा एनसीटीई (नेशनल काउंसिल फार टीचर्स एडूकेशन) ने 23 अगस्त 2010 और 29 जुलाई 2011 को अधिसूचना जारी कर सहायक अध्यापकों की न्यूनतम योग्यता निर्धारित की है। इसलिए बेसिक शिक्षा नियमावली 1981 पर यह बाध्यकारी है।
इस अधिसूचना के विपरीत शिक्षक नियमावली में कोई संशोधन नहीं किया जा सकता है। राज्य सरकार द्वारा पूर्व का विज्ञापन रद कर देने से पूरी चयन प्रक्रिया बदल गई है। टीईटी के प्राप्ताकों को अब मानक के बजाय मात्र अर्हता माना जा रहा है। इस नई परिस्थिति में जो लोग 30 नवंबर 2011 के विज्ञापन में आवेदन की अर्हता नहीं रखते थे, वह भी अब पात्र हो गए हैं। इसकी वजह से प्रतिस्पर्धा बढ़ गई है।
खंडपीठ ने प्रदेश सरकार से जानना चाहा है कि क्या एकल न्यायपीठ ने टीईटी परीक्षा में हुई धांधली और इसमें लिप्त लोगों को अलग करके शेष लोगों का चयन टीईटी केप्राप्तांक पर चयन करने के लिए कहा था। खंडपीठ का मत था कि पिछली सरकार के जाने के बाद नई सरकार ने पूरी चयन प्रक्रिया बदल दी। अब ऐसा भी संभव है कि कोई दूसरी सरकार बने और वह इस सरकार की चयन प्रक्रिया को दोषपूर्ण बताते हुए बदल दे।
Court No. – 33
Case :- SPECIAL APPEAL No. – 150 of 2013
Petitioner :- Navin Srivastava And Others
Respondent :- State Of U.P. And Others
Petitioner Counsel :- Abhishek Srivastava
Respondent Counsel :- C.S.C.
����������������������������������� And
Case :- SPECIAL APPEAL No. – 149 of 2013Petitioner :- Sujeet Singh And Others
Respondent :- State Of U.P. And Others
Petitioner Counsel :- Navin Kumar Sharma,Shailendra
����������������������������������� And
Case :- SPECIAL APPEAL No. – 152 of 2013Petitioner :- Rajeev Kumar Yadav
Respondent :- State Of U.P. And Others
Petitioner Counsel :- Sadanand Mishra,Seemant Singh
Respondent Counsel :- C.S.C.,Shyam Krishna Gupta
����������������������������������� And
Case :- SPECIAL APPEAL No. – 159 of 2013Petitioner :- Anil Kumar And Others
Respondent :- State Of U.P. And Others
Petitioner Counsel :- Siddharth Khare,Ashok Khare
Respondent Counsel :- C.S.C.,A.K. Yadav
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � And
Case :- SPECIAL APPEAL No. – 161 of 2013Petitioner :- Alok Singh And Others
Respondent :- State Of U.P. And Others
Petitioner Counsel :- Abhishek Srivastasva
Respondent Counsel :- C.S.C.,A.K. Yadav,R.A. AkhtarHon’ble Sushil Harkauli,J.
Hon’ble Manoj Misra,J.
������� In this bunch of similar appeals, we have heard learned counsel for the appellants and the learned Additional Advocate General for the State. Connect these appeals and list them together as a bunch on 11.02.2013.
������ All candidates have cleared the TET. One of the basic questions that arises in these cases is that if the criteria for selection is the TET merit, then whether the selection had taken place before the training, or after the training, the result would have been the same. Clause No. 10 of the Advertisement says that after successful completion of training (approved by the NCTE) the substantive appointments would be made as per 1981 Rules and Twelfth amendment 2011. While deciding a case we have to go by the substance. By way of example if the selected candidates had not been called ‘apprentice teachers’, but had been selected on merits merely for ‘training with scholarships equivalent to salary’, and after successful completion of training again subjected to selection as per their merit in TET (which at that time was the prescribed criteria), the result in substance would have been the same as obtaining today. And in such case the ground that there was no post of ‘apprentice teachers’ would not be available.
������� The basis for cancellation of the earlier selection process as mentioned in the order dated 26.07.2012 consists of two kind of grounds. The first ground says that some alleged irregularities were found in conducting of the Teacher Eligibility Test (TET for short). It appears that some High Powered Committee under the Chairmanship of the Chief Secretary gave a report. On the basis of that report, the entire selection process, wherein the merit of the TET was the determining�criteria, was canceled.
������� The learned Single Judge has held in the impugned order that if some irregularities were found at some places, the good part of the TET should have been attempted to be separated from the bad or vitiated part, but the entire selection should not have been canceled.
����� �� So far as there is nothing to show from the side of the State that the good part that is to say places where there was no irregularity in the TET could or could not be separated from the bad part that is from places or areas where irregularities had taken place.
�������� As prayed by the learned Additional Advocate General, the report of the High Powered Committee may be placed on record by means of a counter-affidavit, which will also indicate with cogent reasons, on the basis of that report or other previous records, whether it was, or was not, possible to separate the good part from the bad part.
����� � The second kind of ground of the order dated 26.07.2012 indicates that it was felt that the criteria for determining the merit for selection on the basis of merit in the TET should be replaced by the criteria of determining the merit on the basis of quality point marks as calculated on the basis of past academic record, ignoring the merit of TET. This substituted criteria was believed to be better by way of some after-thought. Accordingly Rules were amended.
������� The learned Single Judge has held in the impugned order that such change of criteria can only be prospective and cannot affect the previous selections.
������� Moreover, we are also prima facie of the opinion that this change of thought namely that the previous criteria could be replaced by seemingly better criteria for determining merit cannot be a ground for canceling the entire selection process. If that kind of ground urged by the State is accepted, it is equally possible that tomorrow some other Government or some other official may think that perhaps the new suggested criteria (of quality point marks) could be replaced by what he believes to be a still better criteria, could again form the basis of scrapping the fresh selection process which is ongoing.
������� In the fresh selection process, there is an extremely large number of candidates whose counseling is said to have started from today.
�������� Obviously, the counseling will take time, and we intend, with the consent of the parties, to finally dispose of all these appeals at the admission stage, for which we have fixed 11.02.2013. Therefore, we are of the opinion that so many candidates should not be put to the trouble of counseling, which may, if these appeals are ultimately allowed, be reduced to a futile exercise. Therefore, keeping in view the larger overall interest of all parties involved, including the interest of those candidates who are not parties before us, we are of the opinion that the ongoing selection process should remain suspended till 11.02.2013. Order accordingly.
Order Date :- 4.2.2013
Sunil Kr Tiwari
(Manoj Misra,J.) (Sushil Harkauli,J.)
We will update this page regarding this news as we get a official information . Visit again after few minutes .
Comments
tet eaxam m ghapla hone k karan ye bharti b.ed merit base pr hona chahiye na k tet bacse pr .:.
tet me marks kam he
YES MERA JI AAP SAHI KAH RAHI HAI
kisi b base pr ho bs bhrti ho hr ladke ki alg alg frmais hai kahan tk puri ki jaye. 9759441739
up me academic base pe kitni nakal hoti h ye b kisi se chipa nhi h
koyi bee barti may niyam beach may nahi badal saktay agar dadhli hui hay to sabuut kaha hay kisi kay khilaf arop lagana koi badi baat nahi hay paisa milnay say ya sabit nahi hota ki dadhli hui BTC Walay isi tet kay adar per pass many gay hay chahay 01 no badha ho ya10 dadhli to dadhli hay
It is necessary to take judgements in right time otherwise it it will be all vague for all of us.
YE KYA HO RAHA HAI, 72825 LOGO KA BHALA HONE DO, FIR AAGE KI LADAI JARI RAKHENGE, HUM LOGO KO EK HOKE HI REHNA CHAHIYE TABHI HUM IS LADAI KO JARI RAKH SAKTE HAIN AUR JEET SAKTE HAI, AISE BIKHRAO SAHI NAHI,,,,,,,,SO JUST THINK ABOUT IT AND THEN DECIDE WHAT SHOULD WE DO???????????? THANKS!
chup be lagta hai tera naam list me hai isiliye kah rahe ho…..ek fresh tet exam hona chaiye..central govt k supervision me
you are saying absolutely correct. phele hamare 72825 bhai behno ke bharti ho jaye.
fir aage dekhna hai ke kya karna hai
i m in and u r in me,,,,,,,,,,just thing dear!!!!!!!!!!1
Navin Srivastava, and other jindabad jindabad
Sujeet Singh And Others jindabad jindabad
Anil Kumar And Others jindabad jindabad
ye sarcar mhilavirodhi our generler virodhi hai
ab isame general virodhi ki kya baat hai…stay to har cast k liye hai naa…kb sudharoge tum jaise log….mtlb har jagah wahi baat le aaoge…..pvt school me bhi try kar lo agar itani hi talented ho aap…pata chal jayega
Soniya sarkar mahila virodhi ho ya na ho par ab hame ye samajhna padega k jab aaj ham ladke aur ladkiyo ko saman maan rahe hai toh aarakshan kaisa hame bhi ladko k barabar ki cut-off se santushti karni padegi….toh keval mudde ki baat karo na!!!!!
ye sirf apne logo ko fayda phuchane keliye hi ye sab ker rhi hai
soniya ji you are right.
koi kuch nhi kr raha sb ladke kr rhe hai rit pr rit akhir sarkar to 1 hi base banayegi jo banaye to oposition me rit to fir cancle hi ho jayengi tb dalna rit jitni dal mile sbko
government ko abhi bhi soch samagh kar bharti karane chahea nahe to patra chale ke niukte milne ke bad high court rad kar de,jo sabse dukhdAE HOGA … government ko phir se tet karake niukte prakriya karane chahea……ese me sabka bhala hai……….
jiuendra kis duniya m ho aap ,, aap ko ye hi nhi pta k tet m dhandali k jkarn hi kyi ooficr ko suspnd kiya gya or aisa kon sa exam h jis k answr sheet kyi baar chng ho wo exam shi kha se ho gya…
Mai aap savi ye puchna chata hu kis vibhag me ghapla nahi hota koi kahta tet pe karo koi kahta acdm. pe akhir karne do to bad me acchar sanhita lag jayega2013 ke last me to ladte rahna apas me
bharti process hoga ki nahi 11 feb. ko. sitapur ki merit khatak ja sakti hai.
yar ladke nhi hone denge kuch b sarkar nhi sb kuch hm or tum hi kr rahe hai
hum log ye bharti tet merit se kara kar rahenge chahe hum logo ko S C tak jana pare THANK ‘S. ALL the best.
han bahi hm bi bharti m.ed ke batagese karakr rahenge, sb apna apna waitage mago or bharti cancle ka aadesh suno conct me 9759441739
are bhaiyo hum log bhi toh yahi baat kbse samjhana chah rahe hai k bharti nahi, TET 2011 radd karo kyonki march 2014 k baad b.ed walon ka kuch nahi hoga aur vacancie bhi 72825 hi toh hai saare TET wale waise bhi nahi ho payenge esse accha 60% b.ed ki merit lagakar sabko mauka diya jaye waise bhi TET 2011 toh niradhar hai hi aur dubara TET karwane ka matlab waqt aur paiso ki barbadi….esliye aapas me ladna chhodo TET aur NON TET sab is bharti me sshami hone chahiye esme kisi ka bhi bura nahi hoga aur aatm santushti bhi hogi k hum shamil hai na koi dharna hoga na koi pradarshan aur shanti purvak bharti bhi ho jayegi……….ESLIYE SABKO MAUKA DO AUR TET KI BADHYATA KHATM KARO KYOKI B.ED APNE AAP ME EK SHIKSHK PATRTA PRASHIKSHAN HAI……
kya b.ed. 2012 wale out hai ya nahi
Pratibha ji,
Bus 11 tak ka wait kariye solution govt nikal rahi hai,………but ab jo bhi prakriya govt le k chal rahi wo as per NCTE he hai, aise me court nahi rok sakti aise bharti ko……….best of luck
11 se pirkirya suru ho jayegi ghabraiye nahi
AK SAAL SE PRAKRIYA CHAL RAHI H PATA NI KAB TAK BHARTI HOGI PAR MAI INTJAAR KARUNGA.
thanks
han ji 11 k bad prakiirya suru ho jayegi,…………..
ES BHARTI M B.ED WALO KO BHI SHAMIL KIYA JAYE.KIYO KI B.ED BHI EK APNE AAP M EK SHIKSHA PATRTA H
Hi
tet ki merit jodi jay sari samsya smapt ho jayegi.mere hisab se tet ki merit-
praptank ka prtisht *20/100 ho jay to lgbhg sabhi ke sath nyay ho jay.
Dosto aplogo ko pta hona chahiye ki NCTE ke rule se ab B.Ed. Wale TET ka 1st Paper nhi de skte h
Kuch news do
Mera aur meri gf ka break up ho gaya..lol
Koi aaj ki letest news batao barti hogi ki nahi.sarkar ne to hum sab ko loot liya
tumlog khud lute ho bharti ho kisi b base pr ho ladke khud nhi hone dete hai bharti fir dos sarkar pr dalte hai
koi kahta tet base koi kahta d.ed base koi kahta p.g ka batage do koi kahta bisist ka batage to akhir sarkar b kya kare
mere khyal se jaise sare ka add karke merit bana hai vase hi tet ka persent add karke merit banana chahiye.
Academic merit me 90% nakalchi,jugadu select honge,kya wo dhandhli nahi hai,isi liye tet merit is the best
ye bharti exam se to jaye to sabki aukat pata chale ki kaun kitne pani me hai. Nakal ke adhar par high school inter graduate B.ed me pass ho gaye hai.
pleasss dhyan dijiyega meri bato pe……….ye bharti honi hi nahi chahiye bcz ye bilkul niradhar hai aise me jiska ho raha hai woh toh yahi chahega k ye bharti honi chahiye par mere janne wale 2012 k bahut se student aise hai jinhe sach me naokri ki jarurat hai sari jama punji b.ed karne laga du ye soch kar k ek baar unki government job lag jayegi toh sab thik ho jayega per tet ki vajah se woh es bharti me shamil hi nahi hi sakte….toh kya aise me ek aisi pariksha ko aadhar bana kar bharti prakriya puri kar leni chahiye jo shuru se hi bebuniyaad rahi hai, aur rahi baat TET karne walon ki toh mai ye nahi kahti k woh cheater hai par TET 2011 ek fake pariksha thi fir jinhone TET clear kar rakha hai aur merit me bhi hai toh unhe pareshan hone ki jarurat woh toh safe hi hai…ab ager mai galat kah rahi hu toh aap log hi bataiye k akhir hona kya chahiye…because you are a teacher, thaks & good night…
teacher ki bharti hogi our b. ed k adhar pe hi hogi, ab sarkar beech me quit nhi kr sakti, agar aisa hua to main us akhilesh yadav ka sar fod dungi.
@Sri Ram:
mr sri ram..aap jaise log jo ye bhi thik se padh sakte ki kis bande k kehne ka kya means hai wo wakayi teacher banne layak nahi… na gov.. and na private..
aap mere liye keh rahe hain ki mai up k baahar se b ed kar aaya hun… aur overage hun…. jabki humne pehle hi likha k hume B ed karne ki koi zarurat hi nahi hai…..
meri age 27 hai.. aur mai itna paisa apne business se hi nakaal leta hun jiska aap jaise log sapna hi dekhte rahenge.. aur gov. teacher bankar bhi nahi kama payenge…
i m owner of a leading mobile shop at etawah.. named : Ashoka mobile, new city, etawah
etawah aa jao aur dekh lo….
ok
agr ladko ka yahi drama raha to fir bharti cancle hi ho jayengi or rah jaoge sb berojgar fir dalte rahna rit pr rit
Friends…. tension nahi lo…..11 feb k baad sab sahi ho jayega….
aur jo log deserve karte hain… unhe mauka zarur milega….
ALL THE BEST ALL (EXCEPT SHRI RAM)
hello frieds me sirf yahi kahna chahta presan hone ki jarurat nahi hai.ye bharti hogi .sp sarkar jarur karayegi,wo to hum me se koi bharti nahi hone dena chahte kyoki wo baar baar yachika lagakar hi bharti me rukabat dal rahe hai .